Monday, May 28, 2012

Review: The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald


   
F. Scott Fitzgerald
1925


An Alexandrine Couplet About The East And West Egg Crowd
J. Gatsby loves Daisy – Daisy loves attention
Tom loves being an ass – Nick loves the West, I guess?

***Magical Bonus Couplet***

An Alexandrine Couplet About Nick’s Friends
They dance and drink champagne – they traipse around New York
dating the wrong people – and it ends tragically


So here’s the thing:  Everyone read this in high school, but it’s a really difficult book to teach.  Having taught it, I think it mostly loses readers in its insanely complex intro, which is really hard to get through.  Alienate a teenager in the first 10 pages and you can’t really expect them to give their full and complete attention to the next two hundred.  So it goes.

Regardless, of all the “classics” of American literature, this is 1 of the 2 best.  I’m not exaggerating – I’ve spent way too much time thinking all this through.  To Kill A Mockingbird is the other.  And here’re 2 reasons why:  1st, Gatsby’s written about a very specific time and place, but it’s easily translatable to other times and places.  It’s as relevant now as it was then.  It’s both history and pop-culture (there’ll be more on this after some pictures of closets).  2nd, it can be read as entertainment or in an educational setting.  But mostly, this book is flawless.  Every word is carefully chosen and perfectly applied.  Every line is pregnant with meaning.  Everything relates to everything.  There’s no wasted space, dialog, or description, and no accidents.  


It’s written like this closet



But it’s fun like this one


We could haggle if we needed.  It always bothered me how Nick forgot his birthday till halfway through the day, though I can defend it if put on the spot.  But 99.9% of this book is impossible to argue with.  If you don’t like it, that’s cool.  That’s a personal choice.  But you can’t say it’s bad

 Living in New York, I saw the lives of people so rich and careless.  And I, as a West Coaster, never entirely fit in there, was never truly accepted by New York, and eventually moved back.  Like Nick, most of my friends in New York weren’t New Yorkers.  Virtually everyone I knew had a great few years and moved again.  New York is filled with people from other places who hang out with people from where they’re from.  F. Scott wrote about it then, and it’s still like that.    

Also, the lifestyle of Gatsby and his world are all very real today in hip-hop culture.  People making it, occasionally in shady ways and occasionally in very honest ones, and then not knowing what to do with themselves.  They’re filthy rich but people who’ve been the 1% for 2 or 3 or 5 generations will never accept them.  They throw lavish parties, drink, dance.  The entire “roaring 20s” thing, with the sexy clothes, the flashy jewelry, the people going out, being part of a “scene,” being photographed, it’s all so like today.  Replace black and white news photos with TMZ, the gin with Cristal, and you’re right there. 

You don’t believe me?


Look at Drake’s backyard . . .




 . . . and Lil Wayne’s vodka add . . .

and tell me I don’t know what I’m talking about.











 

Honestly, I’m not a huge fan of F. Scott’s writing.  But the man didn’t waste any time.  This book paints such an accurate picture, so brilliantly, that it really is awe-inspiring from a writer’s point of view.  Watching Nick watch all these people and getting wrapped up in their stupid, inconsequential lives, and understanding that they’re still people with emotions, hopes, dreams, that they actually take themselves seriously, and having to figure out where to draw the line between sympathy and disgust.  Reading Gatsby is going through all that, but we mostly don’t think about it or even understand it, we just talk about the clothes they wear, the cars they drive, the physical details through which we pretend to know and understand them.  Remind you of the Kardashians?  Think about it. 

The book really is stunning. 

Also:  Yes, the eyes of T.J. Eckleburg are meant to be God.  Just stop arguing and accept it.



God. 




No comments:

Post a Comment